True Crime
NYPD charged Alicia Leslie with criminally negligent homicide in the 2022 death of Maxine Messam.
CBS New York and News 12 reported Thursday, Oct. 22, 2026, that Leslie, 47, of Mount Vernon, was arrested in the Feb. 15, 2022 death of Messam, 53, of Bridgeport. CBS New York, citing the criminal complaint, said Leslie, also known as Toya, injected her with a silicone substance. She is due back in court Nov. 4.
By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer ·
The counts CBS New York lists are criminally negligent homicide and unauthorized practice of a profession. News 12 uses the same two counts and says the NYPD has not released more about Leslie's role. CBS New York says the complaint describes an injection. An arrest and a complaint are the accusation. The next date on CBS New York is Nov. 4. News 12 does not print a court date.
CBS New York and News 12 reported Thursday, Oct. 22, 2026, that Alicia Leslie, 47, of Mount Vernon, New York, was arrested and charged with criminally negligent homicide and unauthorized practice of a profession in the death of Maxine Messam, 53, of Bridgeport, Connecticut. CBS New York said she was arrested Saturday. News 12 said the NYPD said she was arrested Oct. 16. Oct. 16, 2026, was a Friday. Saturday was Oct. 17. The two outlets do not put the arrest on the same calendar day. Both put the death on Feb. 15, 2022, more than four years earlier. CBS New York said she is due back in court on Nov. 4. News 12 did not give a next date.
What the complaint says, and what the department has said in public, are not the same paragraph. CBS New York reported that according to the criminal complaint, Leslie, who is also known as Toya, injected Messam with "a silicone substance." News 12 reported that the NYPD has not released additional details about Leslie's alleged role. A complaint allegation printed by one station and a department silence reported by the other are both in Thursday's coverage. Neither is a finding about how Messam died. The charge of unauthorized practice of a profession is the licensing count both outlets list next to the homicide count. It is not, by itself, a medical finding.
The hospital account is the part they share, with a half-hour gap and a different clock. CBS New York said Messam was dropped off at Jacobi Hospital unconscious, unresponsive and without pants just before 2 a.m. on Feb. 15, 2022, with multiple injection marks on her buttocks. News 12 said two women claiming to be Good Samaritans brought her to Jacobi Medical Center around 1:30 a.m., saying they found her near a cemetery asking for help, and that she was partially unclothed with multiple injection marks on her buttocks. CBS New York said the two women brought her in her own vehicle, pulled her out, loaded her onto a gurney, told staff they found her outside Woodlawn Cemetery in that condition, and then left. News 12 did not name the cemetery and did not describe the car or the gurney. Both said she was pronounced dead. The injection marks are what both say police and the hospital saw. They are not a completed autopsy report in either story.
News 12 added what friends said after the death, which CBS New York's Thursday story does not. The station said friends and family described Messam as a devoted wife, mother and hardworking state employee, and that friends remembered her as someone who "lit the room with her presence." That is recollection. It is not evidence about the procedure. CBS New York's account of the complaint is the only place Thursday's coverage puts Leslie's hands on a syringe. News 12's account stops at the arrest and the old hospital story. All defendants are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.
Shop
Checkout is on Shopify. A few from the rack:
More on the desk

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer
FOX5 said sources reported Michael Sanft dead Thursday night. The Review-Journal said a friend found his body Friday morning.
Thursday night, Friday morning, and Friday with no hour are not the same time. Did not appear suspicious, a medical episode with no markings of foul play, and homicide investigators working the scene are not the same finding. Pending is not a cause of death. Keefe D, on KTNV, and Keffe D, on FOX5, News 3, and USA TODAY, are not the same spelling. A notice of appeal dated Oct. 30 is a filing. It is not the October sentence.
Read the take
Reporting noted by FOX5, Las Vegas Review-Journal, USA TODAY, KTNV, and News 3 Las Vegas.

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer
KCTV5 said Charles Smith-Howell was sentenced to 72 years in Ebony Duncan’s death. The Kansas City Star, KSHB, and KMBC still had the sentencing date as Oct. 5.
A sentence the prosecutor’s office announced on Nov. 6, and a sentencing hearing the July stories placed on Oct. 5, are not the same date. Two counts of tampering, on KCTV5, the Kansas City Star, and KMBC, and tampering in the singular, on KSHB, are not the same count. A bullet wound to the shoulder, on the Star, an autopsy that determined she had been shot, on KSHB, and a homicide ruling with no wound described, on KCTV5, are not the same account of how Ebony Duncan died.
Read the take
Reporting noted by KCTV5, Kansas City Star, KSHB, KMBC, Jackson County Prosecutor's Office, and Independence Police Department.

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer
The Daily Freeman spelled him Nicholas Peterson in the story and Nicholus Peterson in the caption. Daily Voice spelled Nicholus C. Peterson.
Nicholas, and Nicholus, and Nicholus C., are not the same spelling. Arraigned by a grand jury, and arraigned on an indictment before a judge, are not the same proceeding. Twenty-seven times, and 27 times in the head and neck plus once in the abdomen, are not the same count. An indictment is an accusation. It is not a conviction.
Read the take
Reporting noted by Daily Freeman, Daily Voice, Dutchess County District Attorney's Office, and New York State Police.
