Skip to content

True Crime

Amarillo police booked Allen Plumlee on aggravated kidnapping and a third-or-more DWI after a Sunday night crash.

NewsChannel 10 reported that Allen Plumlee, 43, was arrested by Amarillo police around 10:30 p.m. Sunday, Oct. 11, 2026, and booked into the Potter County Jail. The charges are driving while intoxicated, third or more, aggravated kidnapping to facilitate another crime, and interfering with emergency assistance. Police say he crashed a truck and then forced a woman to drive him from a cemetery to a convenience store.

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer ·

An aggravated-kidnapping booking is an accusation. It is not a conviction. The arrest report says a woman told officers she drove because she feared for her life. That statement is the state's account of the ride. It has not been tested in court.

NewsChannel 10, citing the Potter County Jail arrest report, said officers were first called to East I-40 and South Whitaker Road for a vehicle that crashed into a gas meter. A caller said a man in a black jacket and blue jeans walked toward Memorial Park Cemetery. Inside the wrecked vehicle, officers found an open alcohol bottle and documents with Plumlee's name.

While that scene was still open, another 911 call came from the Cefco at West I-40 and Bell Street. The station reported that the woman told officers Plumlee got into her car at the cemetery, yelled at her to drive after she said no, and that she complied because she feared for her life. She said she heard him on the phone saying he was not going back to prison and telling someone not to say anything because he was drunk and had wrecked his truck. When he got out for a beer and told her not to leave, she drove off and called 911. Officers later found him near Plains Boulevard and Wolflin Avenue. He failed three sobriety tests, was treated for a broken hand at Northwest Texas Hospital, and was booked. The station reported prior DWI convictions in Hood and Tarrant counties from 2007 to 2016.

Those earlier convictions are history a prosecutor can offer on a third-or-more DWI count. They are not proof of the kidnapping allegation. All defendants are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.

Share on XEmail

Get the take when the jury is out, the Court drops an order, or we go live.

Shop

Checkout is on Shopify. A few from the rack:

All merch

More on the desk