Skip to content

Trials

A Pima County judge sentenced Andreys Luis Arias to 12 years for the UA library stabbing.

KOLD and KVOA reported Monday, Oct. 12, 2026, that Pima County Superior Court Judge Danielle Constant sentenced Andreys Luis Arias, now 18, to 12 years in state prison and seven years of probation after he pleaded guilty to aggravated assault with a deadly weapon and domestic-violence kidnapping in the Aug. 19, 2025 stabbing of Aaniya Coley at the University of Arizona Main Library. KVOA reported he received credit for 63 days served.

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer ·

A plea and a prison term are the conviction and the sentence on the counts he admitted. They are not a jury trial verdict on attempted murder. KOLD reported prosecutors described a planned attack. Judge Constant called it classic domestic-violence coercive control. The sentence is 12 years plus seven years of probation. It is the judgment.

KOLD reported Monday, Oct. 12, 2026, that Andreys Luis Arias, who was 17 when he was arrested and is now 18, will spend more than a decade in prison after admitting he stabbed his then-girlfriend, Aaniya Coley, at the University of Arizona Main Library on Aug. 19, 2025. KVOA reported Judge Danielle Constant sentenced him to nearly 12 years in prison followed by seven years of probation, and that he pleaded guilty this summer to felony aggravated assault and kidnapping charges. KOLD named the counts as aggravated assault with a deadly weapon and domestic violence kidnapping. KVOA reported he will receive credit for 63 days served as part of the 12-year sentence. A plea is a conviction on the counts admitted. Monday's hearing imposed the term.

KOLD reported prosecutor John Strader told the judge Arias intentionally brought Coley to an isolated location and planned the attack, and that she suffered nine stab wounds to her back, two to her chest, and multiple cuts to her face as Arias followed and attacked her from behind while she tried to escape. KVOA reported Constant cited text messages, internet search history, and his selection of the location, and quoted her saying he brought a knife and a Taser, did not use the Taser, and repeatedly stabbed the victim. KVOA reported both were minors at the time of the attack and had been dating about three years. Prosecutors previously said she suffered a punctured lung and was stabbed in the eye, KVOA reported. Those are the injuries and planning allegations as the stations summarized the hearing and earlier filings.

KOLD reported Constant said she had never seen a clearer example of premeditation in a violent case, considered his age and other mitigating factors, and still called it classic domestic violence. KVOA quoted her: "You needed to control everything and when she wasn't being controlled, you could not take it." KOLD reported Arias apologized in court and said he wished he could take it back. KVOA reported he said he hoped his former girlfriend could eventually forgive him. A defendant's apology is advocacy at sentencing. It is not the judgment. Coley and her family were present, KOLD reported. Naming her is how KOLD and KVOA identified the adult survivor at the sentencing hearing. She is not pictured here.

Twelve years in prison and seven years of probation are the sentence Judge Constant imposed on the plea counts. They are not a finding on a charge he did not plead to. All defendants are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.

Share on XEmail

Get the take when the jury is out, the Court drops an order, or we go live.

Shop

Checkout is on Shopify. A few from the rack:

All merch

More on the desk

Booking photo of Marcus Ballinger Jr.
Trials

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer

A La Porte County jury convicted Marcus Ballinger Jr. of murder in Devin Porter's death.

A murder conviction is a jury finding beyond a reasonable doubt. It is not the sentence. Indiana's murder range runs 45 to 65 years, WIMS and Hometown News Now reported. Nov. 5 is when the court decides the term. The May arrest and the October verdict are months apart. The charge became a conviction. The sentence has not been imposed.

Read the take

Reporting noted by WSBT, ABC57, WIMS, and Hometown News Now.

Florida Department of Corrections photo of James Robertson
Trials

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer

Florida executed James Robertson at 12:31 p.m. His last words were "Naw, I'm straight."

A completed execution is not the same as a scheduled warrant. The Port Charlotte Sun reported a time of death and last words from the chamber. The Associated Press account carried by the Los Angeles Times reported he was pronounced dead at 12:32 p.m. Those times are one minute apart. The guilty plea and the death sentence were already the judgment for Frank Hart's killing. What changed Tuesday is that Florida carried the sentence out.

Read the take

Reporting noted by Port Charlotte Sun, Associated Press, Los Angeles Times, NBC News, CBS Miami, Sarasota Herald-Tribune, Gulf Coast News, and Florida Supreme Court.

Payton Gendron at his Erie County sentencing
Trials

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer

Jury selection began Tuesday in Payton Gendron's federal hate-crimes trial.

The state case is over. Gendron pleaded guilty, and an Erie County judge sentenced him on Feb. 15, 2023, to life in prison without parole. The federal prosecution is not that case. A jury is not seated yet. Nothing in the federal indictment has been proved. If a jury convicts him, the government wants death, and life in prison is the other outcome. The next several weeks are about who is allowed to sit.

Read the take

Reporting noted by Associated Press, 13WHAM, Buffalo Toronto Public Media, WBEN, WKBW, and U.S. Attorney's Office for the Western District of New York.