Skip to content

True Crime

Husband Charged in West Allis Death

Benjamin Carpenter, 45, is charged with first-degree intentional homicide in the Oct. 13, 2024, death of his wife, Erica Carpenter, 40, at their West Allis home. He told police she collapsed in the basement and that they fell on the stairs. A commissioner set a $500,000 cash bond, and a preliminary hearing is Dec. 8.

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer ·

Booking photo of Benjamin Carpenter
Photo: Milwaukee County Sheriff's Office via New York Post

Erica Carpenter is dead, and the medical examiner still lists no cause. The charge is the state's claim that her husband meant to kill her, built from searches, a sleep drug, insurance calls, and his training in chokes. A preliminary hearing has to test that accusation. It is not a verdict.

West Allis police arrested Benjamin Carpenter, 45, on Tuesday morning and charged him with first-degree intentional homicide in the death of his wife, Erica Carpenter, 40. On the evening of Oct. 13, 2024, officers went to their home on South 95th Street for a welfare check. They found her at the bottom of the basement stairs, bleeding from the head, while he performed CPR. She was taken to a hospital and pronounced dead the next day. He told police she collapsed while they were doing laundry, that he tried to carry her upstairs, and that he slipped. He said both of them fell and that she hit her head on a cinder-block wall.

The medical examiner's office ruled the cause of death undetermined. That office said the death may have resulted from asphyxia and noted a blunt-force injury to her neck. Court papers call the death highly suspicious and concerning for asphyxia, and they describe blunt-force injuries to her head and neck. A toxicology report found doxylamine, a sleep medication, and hydrocodone. Investigators questioned him about his background as a jiu-jitsu black belt and about a choke. They also wrote that he planned her death about a month beforehand.

Court records describe texts from Erica in the weeks before she died. She wrote that a powdery substance had been in her water at least twice. He told her she had been drinking his water, which he said was mixed with Liquid IV. Charging documents say that on the same day he searched "losing someone," "watching someone you love die," and a page of quotes about the death of a loved one. On the day she collapsed, the complaint says, he searched whether pills can be crushed and taken in water.

He admitted an affair and said he had planned to ask Erica for a divorce the same weekend she died. The other woman had told him she would not date him until he was divorced. Financial records reviewed by police show that three days after the funeral he bought a diamond bracelet for $3,754. He called an insurer about a $300,000 life insurance policy on Erica after telling investigators he did not know she had one. Investigators say he collected more than $200,000 from one of her policies in the days after she died. Those records describe about $22,000 from a GoFundMe and about $6,000 from a pub crawl. The fundraiser's public total is now more than $28,000.

He appeared Wednesday before Milwaukee County Court Commissioner Rosa Barillas. She set a $500,000 cash bond. A preliminary hearing is set for Dec. 8. If he is convicted, the charge carries life in prison.

All defendants are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.

Share on XEmail

Get the take when the jury is out, the Court drops an order, or we go live.

Shop

Checkout is on Shopify. A few from the rack:

All merch

More on the desk