Skip to content

Explainers

Charlotte Moves to Dismiss Zarutska Suit

The City of Charlotte asked a judge on Monday to throw out the wrongful-death lawsuit filed by Iryna Zarutska's uncle. The city says governmental immunity and the public-duty doctrine bar the claims.

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer ·

Monday's motion tests the complaint against immunity and the public-duty doctrine. A judge who grants it can end the estate's claims against the city on the pleadings. The criminal prosecution stays on its own docket.

Charlotte filed a motion on Monday, Nov. 16, in Mecklenburg County Superior Court to dismiss the wrongful-death suit over the killing of Iryna Zarutska. Her uncle, Frank Haskell, sued in August as administrator of her estate. The civil defendants are the city and the security contractor, Professional Police Services, also called Professional Security Services. A mediation this month ended without a settlement. The city wants the claims against it dismissed, and it wants that dismissal with prejudice where the law allows. A dismissal with prejudice would stop the same complaint from being filed again.

Zarutska was 23. She was stabbed on a Charlotte Area Transit System light-rail train on Aug. 22, 2025, and she died. The city's papers call her death an intentional criminal attack by DeCarlos Brown Jr. The city denies that it ignored passenger safety, and it denies that its own conduct legally caused the attack. Brown is charged with murder in that killing. He is in federal custody, and a state court date in the murder case was continued to May 4, 2027. He has not been convicted. All persons are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.

The city says the suit takes aim at governmental work: where officers are deployed, transit policing, crime prevention, oversight of a security contractor, and the administration of public safety. It says those are governmental functions covered by governmental immunity. It also relies on the public-duty doctrine. General police protection, on that argument, is a duty owed to the public, and the complaint does not allege a specific promise of protection to Zarutska or a special relationship with her. The city says systemwide crime numbers do not make this attack foreseeable, and that Brown's act was an independent cause. It says the security company was an independent contractor, so the city is not answerable for that company's alleged negligence, and that the complaint does not state a claim for gross negligence.

If any claim against the city goes forward, Charlotte asks the judge to cap what it could pay at a cumulative $1 million and to leave immunity in place above that limit. The city also says punitive damages cannot be awarded against a municipality. The reports of Monday's filing did not include a hearing date.

Share on XEmail

Get the take when the jury is out, the Court drops an order, or we go live.

Shop

Checkout is on Shopify. A few from the rack:

All merch

More on the desk