Skip to content

True Crime

Diego Sarabia asked a judge to dismiss Jane Doe's claims against him in the Cornell lawsuit.

NBC News reported Oct. 25, 2026, that Sarabia filed a motion Friday seeking dismissal of every claim against him. His lawyer, James C. Knox, wrote that as to Sarabia the suit is "essentially a lawsuit about a forced kiss," and that the claims are too late or legally insufficient. The court has not ruled. Jane Doe is not being named. No one has been criminally charged.

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer · · Updated

A motion to dismiss is a request. It is not a finding that the allegations are false, and it is not a criminal charge. NBC News reported Knox asked the judge to treat the complaint's facts as true for this motion and still throw the claims out. The Oct. 16 refusal of his gag-order request is a different ruling. It still stands.

NBC News reported Oct. 25, 2026, that Diego Sarabia, one of seven men named in Jane Doe's lawsuit over an alleged assault at Cornell University's Chi Phi house, filed a motion Friday asking a judge to dismiss all claims against him. The station's story is dated Sunday. The Friday it describes is Oct. 23. NBC News reported the suit was filed Sept. 16 and concerns Oct. 19 to 20, 2024. It reported the filing says he denies the allegations, and that his lawyers argue that even if the complaint's factual allegations are accepted as true for this motion, the claims against him were filed too late, are legally insufficient, or both. Los Angeles Magazine reported the court has not ruled. A motion is a request.

NBC News reported James C. Knox wrote that, as far as the allegations against his client, "this is essentially a lawsuit about a forced kiss." The station reported the complaint accuses Sarabia of grabbing her face, kissing her, and snorting ketamine off her body with other fraternity members in a room it called the alumni room. Knox wrote, "Throughout a sprawling complaint approaching 600 paragraphs, plaintiff repeatedly, collectively and without differentiation accuses seven student defendants of 'sexual assault and rape,'" and that "Those legally conclusory statements do not substitute for pleaded facts," NBC News reported. The station reported he argued the complaint did not allege that Sarabia supplied her with drugs or alcohol, took part in the sexual encounters described elsewhere, or was present for most of the conduct behind the broader allegations, and that assault, battery, and intentional-infliction claims are barred by a one-year statute of limitations and do not qualify for the longer period the complaint cites. Los Angeles Magazine reported the filing is 16 pages and that the papers argue she does not accuse him of penetration. Those are arguments in a motion. They are not findings. NBC News reported Jane Doe's lawyer, Thomas Giuffra, declined to comment on Sunday. The woman is not named here. No criminal charges have been filed. The Oct. 16 decision on his gag-order request is a separate ruling, set out below.

On Friday, Oct. 16, 2026, Judge Phaedra F. Perry-Bond of New York County Supreme Court filed a decision declining to sign Diego Sarabia's proposed order restricting extrajudicial statements in Jane Doe's lawsuit against Cornell University and seven men, CNY Central and TMZ reported. She wrote that courts typically do not explain such refusals, but that she was doing so "because of the weighty issues involved and the dynamic circumstances of this case." She applied a three-part test: whether there is a serious risk of prejudice to an ongoing proceeding, whether less restrictive means exist, and whether the restriction is narrowly tailored. She found that isolated statements, such as Jane Doe's attorney expressing opinions or alleging intentional destruction of evidence, do not create a serious risk of prejudice, because defendants can rebut them and juries can be instructed. She found that most of the statements were expressions of opinion, that the proposed restrictions were overly broad, and that they could conflict with Cornell's legal obligations, including mandatory reporting, CNY Central reported. She called the proposed order a "side show" and urged the parties to work together on a framework for future filings and statements.

Perry-Bond also criticized Sarabia's lawyers for attaching an email from an attorney who has not appeared in the case, sent to another lawyer, CNY Central and TMZ reported. She called the inclusion "most offensive" and "mudslinging" aimed at attracting tabloid reporting. TMZ reported she described the target as "salacious tabloid reporting." She said the email was tantamount to a threat, ordered it stricken from the record, and gave counsel until Oct. 20 to redact it. She warned that future conduct of this kind could bring sanctions.

TMZ reported Monday, Oct. 12, 2026, that lawyers for Diego Sarabia, one of seven men named in the civil lawsuit brought by the former Cornell student identified as Jane Doe, asked a New York judge to rein in public statements by her attorney, Thomas Giuffra. The papers themselves are NYSCEF document 49, an attorney affirmation by James C. Knox, and document 50, a memorandum of law. Both were filed with the New York County Clerk at 7:45 p.m. on Friday, Oct. 9, 2026, in Jane Doe v. Cornell University, Inc. et al., Index No. 161704/2026. Knox and Alishah Bhimani, of Hacker Murphy LLP in Albany, signed for Sarabia. The memorandum says the suit concerns allegations of sexual assault and related claims from events Jane Doe alleges occurred on the night of Oct. 19, 2024, and the morning of Oct. 20, 2024, while she was an undergraduate at Cornell. It says she seeks damages and has demanded a jury trial. Knox's affirmation says the case is still at the start: some parties have not appeared, no answers have been filed, and discovery has not begun. He says no earlier application for this relief was made. A filing is a request. It is not a signed order.

What the papers ask for is a limit on the people in the case, not on reporters. The memorandum says Sarabia wants narrowly tailored restrictions on extrajudicial statements by the parties and their counsel, together with interim relief pending the return date. It says the proposed order would not restrain the press, close the courtroom, or cut off access to judicial records that remain public. It says the limits would reach participating parties, their attorneys, and their legal representatives, and would use a substantial-likelihood-of-material-prejudice standard. Knox's affirmation says the same thing: the relief is directed only to participating attorneys and parties, and it does not seek to restrain the press. TMZ reported that the proposed order would apply to both sides, limiting what they can say publicly and stopping them from sharing private information or evidence that has not been made public. The papers also ask the court to schedule a return date. They do not print one. TMZ did not report that a judge had granted the request.

The affirmation's examples are television statements it attributes to Giuffra. It says that on Oct. 2, 2026, he told CBS that Jane Doe "didn't have consent from the time she walked in the door; she was incapable of consent," and that he said, "I'm more and more convinced there was a cover-up." It says that on Oct. 5 he told CNN that the fraternity held meetings with the intention to "cover up" what had happened, and that it was interested in "protecting the fraternity, protecting the fraternity brothers and keeping it as business as usual – not justice." It says that on Oct. 2 he told NBC that Jane Doe was "hanging on by a string" and that "This has upended her life in such a tragic way." The affirmation says those are examples, not a full list, and that Giuffra has also addressed the credibility, character, and reputation of defendants. TMZ reported Monday that the lawyers described an "orchestrated campaign" and pointed to interviews in which Giuffra accused Cornell of a cover-up, claimed evidence was destroyed, and suggested more men may have taken part in the alleged assault. Knox uses the words "orchestrated campaign" and says reporting indicated the publicity was planned. He cites a CNN interview in which Cornell Daily Sun senior editor Cereese Qusba said she had communicated with Jane Doe and her lawyers before the suit was filed. Those are the lawyers' characterizations of interviews. They have not been tested as evidence.

Update, Oct. 16, 2026: Jane Doe's attorney, Thomas Giuffra, filed a letter on Wednesday, Oct. 14, opposing the proposed gag order, The Washington Post and CNY Central reported. Giuffra wrote that courts may issue gag orders in appropriate circumstances but argued that barring him from speaking on his client's behalf here would violate the First Amendment, and CNY Central reported he called the request premature and overly broad. He denied leaking Cornell's confidential Title IX records, saying he has them but turned down reporters' requests for them, and he wrote that representatives of the defendants had leaked the records to push a narrative favorable to their clients. Teny Geragos, who represents one of the defendants, told The Washington Post that any suggestion she leaked anything is false and demanded a retraction from Giuffra. On Thursday, Oct. 15, Sarabia's lawyers, James C. Knox and Alishah Bhimani, answered in court papers that neither they nor their client had given any statement or document to the media, called Giuffra's assertions factually incorrect and needlessly inflammatory, and renewed the request for a gag order, the Post reported.

Cornell also responded on Wednesday, CNY Central reported. The university asked the judge to clarify the proposed order so it would not force Cornell to restrict the speech of students, staff and community members who are not parties to the case, said it does not oppose Jane Doe proceeding under a pseudonym, and asked that any protective order also shield the identities of witnesses interviewed in its Title IX process. Those Wednesday and Thursday filings were the record before Judge Perry-Bond when she ruled on Friday.

The same Friday's sealing order is the backdrop the papers use, not a ruling on this motion. Knox says the court had already found that information in filed documents was used to threaten and dox a nonparty's family after an erroneous address was associated with a defendant. He says the court's Oct. 9, 2026 decision and order called the reported threats and doxing dangerous internet vigilantism, sealed NYSCEF documents 1, 6, 7, and 22, and ordered Jane Doe to refile redacted versions that omit purported addresses. Crime Talk Network is not naming that family. The woman in the lawsuit is referred to only as Jane Doe. This motion is in the civil case. No one has been criminally charged. Attorney General Letitia James is the special prosecutor reviewing the matter, which is separate from whether a judge limits what the civil parties and their lawyers say outside court. All defendants are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.

Share on XEmail

Get the take when the jury is out, the Court drops an order, or we go live.

Shop

Checkout is on Shopify. A few from the rack:

All merch

More on the desk