Skip to content

Explainers

Partial Win Can Reopen the Sentence

The Colorado Supreme Court held 5-2 on Monday that a trial judge may resentence a defendant on a count that survives when an appeal knocks out another count and cuts the total prison term, if the remand never says otherwise.

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer ·

Winning the merger cut the term from 44 years to 22, and the state can now ask the trial judge to put time back on the burglary count. The majority did not order a longer sentence. It said the judge may leave the 22 years in place, and if the judge reopens the count the hearing has to look at the person as he stands now, which is the argument to make before anyone treats the old total as the target.

The Colorado Supreme Court on Monday decided Hernandez-Escajeda v. People, 2026 CO 69, No. 24SC802. Justice Carlos A. Samour Jr. wrote for the majority. Justices Brian D. Boatright, William W. Hood III, Maria E. Berkenkotter, and Susan J. Blanco joined. Chief Justice Monica M. Márquez dissented, joined by Justice Richard L. Gabriel.

Octavio Hernandez-Escajeda pleaded guilty in Jefferson County to first-degree burglary, first-degree assault, and a crime-of-violence sentence enhancer. Each felony carried 10 to 32 years, and the plea called for consecutive sentences. The judge gave him 22 years on each count, 44 years in all. He did not appeal the plea. In a later postconviction case, the Court of Appeals held that the assault was a lesser included offense of the burglary and had to merge into it. That left the 22-year burglary sentence. The remand told the trial court to vacate the assault conviction and correct the mittimus.

The trial judge did only that. He read the remand as leaving him no room to resentence the burglary. A second division of the Court of Appeals disagreed. The Supreme Court agreed with that division. When a partial reversal unravels a sentencing package and lowers the total, and the remand is silent on resentencing, the trial court may resentence on a count that remains. It does not have to. If it does, it should hold a new hearing and consider the full set of sentencing factors, including what has happened since the first sentence. It can still leave the remaining sentence as it is. The court said this is not permission to ignore a remand, and it asked appellate courts to say in the remand whether resentencing is on the table.

Márquez wrote that the first remand was specific. It told the trial court to vacate the assault and correct the mittimus, and that is what the judge did. She wrote that a specific mandate is the limit of the trial court's power, and that silence is not an invitation to do more. She also wrote that People v. Johnson, the 2015 case the majority relied on, was different, because that remand ordered a new sentence.

Share on XEmail

Get the take when the jury is out, the Court drops an order, or we go live.

Shop

Checkout is on Shopify. A few from the rack:

All merch

More on the desk