Skip to content

Trials

Jury Convicts Barbier in 1966 Killing

A Cook County jury found James Barbier guilty of first-degree murder in the Nov. 12, 1966 stabbing death of Karen Snider, 18, in her Calumet City home. He has not been sentenced.

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer ·

James Barbier
Photo: Cook County Circuit Court

Sixty years on, the jury still found first-degree murder. The sentence is not set. Prosecutors said a new test of blood from the house identified him, and the defense told the jury that sample was too old and too incomplete to carry the case. Dec. 14 is the next date, and the judge left open whether the term will follow the law from 1966 or the law now.

A Cook County jury on Nov. 9 found James Barbier guilty of first-degree murder. Karen Snider was 18. She was stabbed to death in the upstairs bedroom of her home on Wilson Avenue in Calumet City on Nov. 12, 1966. Jurors deliberated about two hours. Judge Patrick Coughlin revoked Barbier's release and ordered him held until sentencing. Post-trial motions are set for Dec. 14.

Her husband, Paul Snider, was at work at the Indiana Harbor Belt Railroad. Prosecutors told the jury she let Barbier in. He worked with Paul, he had been in the home before, and he lived then in Gary, Indiana. Assistant State's Attorney Krystyn Dilillo told the jury he stabbed Karen Snider 125 times. The autopsy described wounds to her neck, chest, heart, liver, and lungs, and defensive wounds on her hands. An infant daughter was in the house and was not hurt.

Prosecutors said Barbier was a pallbearer at her funeral. He was a suspect in 1966 and was not charged. Calumet City police reopened the case in 2022. Blood from the house was tested with DNA methods that did not exist then, and prosecutors said the result pointed to him. Police arrested him in 2024 at his home in St. Louis County, outside Creve Coeur. He was 79.

The defense told the jury the DNA was degraded, far short of a complete profile, and that much of the original evidence was gone. The jury convicted him. Coughlin said the defense may choose whether the sentence is set under current law or under the law as it stood in 1966. Snider's daughter, Paula Larson, now 60, said after the verdict, "I hope that he never gets to breathe air outside again."

Share on XEmail

Get the take when the jury is out, the Court drops an order, or we go live.

Shop

Checkout is on Shopify. A few from the rack:

All merch

More on the desk