Skip to content

Explainers

Ohio Court Rejects Drug-Dog Delay

The Ohio Supreme Court held 6-1 on Tuesday that police may not prolong a traffic stop in the name of officer safety so they can run a drug dog around the car. The court reversed John Kincaid's case and sent it back to Meigs County.

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer ·

Rodriguez already took a dog sniff out of the mission of a traffic stop, and officer safety does not put it back in. The state had the burden to show the traffic work was still underway when the dog alerted, and this record did not show that. Five or ten minutes is still a seizure once the ticket work is done.

The Supreme Court of Ohio on Tuesday reversed a Meigs County drug case and sent it back. In State v. Kincaid, Slip Opinion No. 2026-Ohio-4510, Chief Justice Sharon L. Kennedy wrote that officer safety does not justify holding a driver so police can run a drug dog, because a sniff is not part of the traffic stop. Justices Patrick F. Fischer, R. Patrick DeWine, Jennifer Brunner, Joseph T. Deters, and Daniel R. Hawkins joined. Justice Megan E. Shanahan dissented.

On December 26, 2019, Meigs County Sheriff's Deputy Tylun Campbell stopped John Kincaid for two marked-lane violations. Campbell had already run the plate and knew the car was registered to him. He testified that he had prior information Kincaid was trafficking drugs in the county, and the state did not produce the source of that information. After Campbell told him why he had been stopped, he decided to walk a dog around the car and called for backup. He waited about five to ten minutes, citing officer safety. The dog alerted at the driver's door. A search found heroin and fentanyl under the driver's seat.

Kincaid pleaded no contest to the trafficking counts. The other charges were dismissed. He was sentenced to three to four and a half years, and the court ordered forfeiture of $1,570 found in the car. The Fourth District affirmed, calling the short wait for backup reasonable. The Supreme Court reversed. Kennedy wrote that Rodriguez v. United States does not let police extend the seizure for a sniff when the safety concern is not about finishing the traffic stop. The state had to prove the ordinary tasks of the stop were still going when the dog alerted. Campbell did not testify that they were, and the timing logs were never introduced.

Shanahan agreed that officer safety is not, standing alone, a reason to hold someone for a dog. She would have affirmed. She wrote that the license checks and the short wait supported an inference that the stop was not finished when the dog alerted. The majority ordered the drugs suppressed and remanded the case. All defendants are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.

Share on XEmail

Get the take when the jury is out, the Court drops an order, or we go live.

Shop

Checkout is on Shopify. A few from the rack:

All merch

More on the desk