Skip to content

Trials

Hochul appoints Letitia James special prosecutor in the Cornell Chi Phi case

On Thursday, Oct. 1, 2026, New York Gov. Kathy Hochul signed an executive order appointing Attorney General Letitia James to investigate an alleged sexual assault reported at Cornell University's Chi Phi fraternity house on Oct. 19-20, 2024. The order removes Tompkins County District Attorney Matthew Van Houten from the case.

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer ·

New York Attorney General Letitia James speaks at a news conference
Photo: Reuters

This is analysis, not a finding about what happened that night. Appointing a special prosecutor changes who can investigate and who can take a case to a grand jury, and a grand jury hears a prosecutor's evidence rather than trying the case. The sworn statement a district attorney actually received is the document measured against the elements of a New York offense, which is why the fight over that six-page statement is about charging authority.

Hochul's Executive Order No. 64, signed Oct. 1, requires the attorney general to investigate and, if warranted, present evidence to a grand jury and prosecute offenses arising from the allegations in a civil complaint filed in New York County. The order says James's jurisdiction displaces and supersedes the Tompkins County district attorney. On Friday, Oct. 2, James said her office had opened an active criminal investigation. She said the office will review the facts, gather evidence, interview witnesses, and, if warranted, pursue prosecutions.

Van Houten's office declined to bring charges in November 2024. On Sept. 27 and 28, 2026, he said he was reopening the matter and preparing it for a Tompkins County grand jury. He has said the six-page sworn statement his office received did not allege nonconsensual conduct under New York law, and he has said he supports handing the case to James. ABC News reported on Oct. 3 that documents show the district attorney's office, in November 2024, declined to review Cornell police interview material beyond that six-page summary of the woman's statement.

In mid-September 2026, the woman, identified in court papers as Jane Doe, filed a civil lawsuit in Manhattan against seven men, the fraternity, Cornell, and others. Cornell has said it supports the special prosecutor and an outside review of how the university handled the case. One former member, identified in a separate court case only as John Doe, sued Cornell to clear a disciplinary finding from his academic record. Reporting says a judge dismissed that case and that an appeal is pending. No one has been charged, and the men named in the civil suit deny the allegations.

Share on XEmail

Get the take when the jury is out, the Court drops an order, or we go live.

Shop

Checkout is on Shopify. A few from the rack:

All merch

More on the desk

Booking photo of Jennifer Stately
Trials

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer

Valley News Live said Jennifer Stately’s life terms run at the same time, with five years of supervised release and a $600 assessment. CBS Minnesota said life in prison and first-degree arson, and did not name the judge.

Life on all counts at the same time, plus five years of supervised release and a $600 assessment, and a life sentence with none of those terms on the page, are not the same sentence. First-degree arson, and arson, are not the same charge name. Red Lake Tribal Nation, the Red Lake Indian Reservation, the Red Lake Nation, and the Red Lake Reservation are not the same place name. Stab wounds, and sharp force injuries, are not the same wound line.

Read the take

Reporting noted by CBS Minnesota, Valley News Live, InForum, Northern News Now, and Star Tribune.

Cooper Ouellette in court
Trials

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer

NBC Connecticut said Cooper Ouellette will be sentenced January 12, 2027, and spelled him Ouelette. FOX61 said that date is a pre-sentencing hearing and the sentencing date is not set.

Manslaughter in the second degree, second-degree manslaughter, and second-degree vehicular manslaughter are not the same charge name. A decade plus a year-and-a-half, 10 years plus 11 months, and a maximum of 23 years are not the same penalty. $200,000, on FOX61, and a request to increase the bond with no dollar figure, on Courtroom Insider, are not the same bond line. He was 19 at the time, on NBC Connecticut, FOX61, and WFSB. He was 18, on Court TV and Courtroom Insider.

Read the take

Reporting noted by NBC Connecticut, FOX61, WFSB, Court TV, and Courtroom Insider.

Booking photo of Jaida McGrew
Trials

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer

News On 6 said a jury found Jaida McGrew guilty of murder in the first degree. The Tulsa World said second-degree murder.

Murder in the first degree, first-degree murder, and second-degree murder are not the same charge name. A deadly weapon, and a dangerous weapon, are not the same word. A jury recommendation, a 15-year term stated in one sentence, and a judge who has not yet sentenced, are not the same step. The News On 6 headline says a man. The update names Jaida McGrew. The Tulsa World says a woman. Those are not the same identification.

Read the take

Reporting noted by News On 6, Tulsa World, and Tulsa Police.