Reddington wants a look at the holdout. A motion is not a misconduct finding.

A defense motion to investigate a holdout juror is advocacy and a request for judicial inquiry. It is not a finding of juror misconduct, not a dismissal, and not a verdict. Impounding questionnaires is process. Lindsay Clancy still faces three first-degree murder counts after a mistrial, and the Sept. 29 Plymouth Superior Court date is a calendar entry, not a result.

On Monday, Sept. 21, 2026, defense attorney Kevin Reddington filed a motion for Lindsay Clancy asking Judge William Sullivan, who oversaw the mistrial, to investigate holdout juror Michael Desronvil. The motion claims Desronvil may have inaccurately filled out jury forms or answered voir dire questions. It also asks the judge to examine an alleged domestic-violence history and cellphone use during deliberations, according to a motion obtained by the New Haven Register and reported by the New York Post. Those are requests in a filing. They are not findings that a form was false, that a voir dire answer was inaccurate, that a domestic-violence history exists, or that a phone was used in the jury room. Judge Sullivan has agreed to impound jury information and questionnaires. He has not ruled on the motion.

Reporting describes Desronvil as the sole juror for guilt on the murder counts, with 11 others for not guilty on a postpartum-psychosis theory. A reported split is not a verdict. The first trial already ended in a mistrial, so the charges remain unresolved. Clancy is charged with three counts of first-degree murder in the Jan. 24, 2023 deaths in Duxbury of her children Callan, then 8 months, Cora, 5, and Dawson, 3. Those names and ages are charging facts from reporting. They are not a finding of guilt. She attempted suicide afterward, is paralyzed, and used a wheelchair at trial, as reported. She is due back in Plymouth Superior Court in Massachusetts on Sept. 29. Reddington is expected to seek dismissal. DA Tim Cruz is expected to say whether there will be a retrial. An expectation and a return date are process. All defendants are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.