Skip to content

Trials

Sullivan set Clancy's gag-order request, dismissal motion and juror inquiry for Nov. 2.

On Tuesday, Sept. 29, 2026, Lindsay Clancy appeared in person in Plymouth Superior Court for the first time since the Sept. 4 mistrial. Judge William Sullivan set the next hearing for Nov. 2, for a prosecution gag-order request, the defense motion to dismiss, and a requested juror inquiry. He did not dismiss the case, order a retrial, or enter a verdict.

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer · · Updated

Lindsay Clancy in court
Photo: Reuters

A hearing without a ruling leaves the case where it was. On Sept. 29, Kevin Reddington argued there is no evidence Lindsay Clancy admitted she killed her children, and Assistant District Attorney Shanan Buckingham called that argument laughable. Prosecutors asked Sullivan to gag the lawyers. He put that request, the dismissal motion, and the juror inquiry on for Nov. 2, and he said the date does not indicate how he will rule. District Attorney Timothy Cruz still has not decided whether to retry the case.

Lindsay Clancy appeared in person on Tuesday, Sept. 29, 2026, the first time since the Sept. 4 mistrial. Defense lawyer Kevin Reddington argued for a finding of not guilty and a dismissal for insufficient evidence. Good Morning America reported he told Judge William Sullivan, "This entire case is based on speculation," and, "There is no evidence that she admitted she did this." He asked, "Where is the evidence that she did this?" and called the investigation "horrific, ridiculous." Assistant District Attorney Shanan Buckingham called that a "laughable argument." "For the first time, the defendant is arguing that there's no evidence that she did this," she said, according to Good Morning America. "I suggest to you that the entire record is voluminous as to the information supporting the fact that she did this." She said defense counsel can argue Clancy was psychotic, and that the argument does not mean the Commonwealth has failed to prove otherwise with evidence of her conduct. Prosecutors Jennifer Sprague and Buckingham told the court the Commonwealth met its burden, and that the 12 jurors had failed to reach a unanimous verdict. Martin Weinberg is counsel on related filings. Argument from counsel is not a ruling. The charges remain unresolved.

Plymouth District Attorney Timothy Cruz told WBZ after the hearing that his office has not decided whether to seek a retrial. He said the office is still proceeding as though a second trial may come, and that it is waiting on motions. Good Morning America reported he told reporters outside court that a decision would come "as soon as we get all the information that we can," and that the office is doing "a very thorough review right now" in the interests of justice and of the three children. An undecided retrial is not a retrial order. Both sides resisted Judge Sullivan's push to pick a new trial date that Tuesday. Reddington said he cannot hold a new trial before next June. No retrial date was set.

Buckingham and Sprague have asked for a gag order going forward, arguing it is necessary to "prevent the carnival atmosphere" witnessed during the trial, Good Morning America reported. Sullivan did not rule on it Tuesday. He set the next hearing for Nov. 2, 2026, and Good Morning America reported he said arguments that day will cover the gag order, the defense motion to dismiss, and the defense push for a juror inquiry. A separate request to investigate holdout juror Michael Desronvil was already pending. Counsel for Desronvil raised privacy and impoundment issues. No separate juror hearing was granted on Sept. 29. A request for a gag order is not itself a gag order, and a request to question a juror is not a finding that the juror did anything wrong. The calendar moved. The case did not. All defendants are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.

Share on XEmail

Get the take when the jury is out, the Court drops an order, or we go live.

Shop

Checkout is on Shopify. A few from the rack:

All merch

More on the desk

Booking photo of Jennifer Stately
Trials

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer

Valley News Live said Jennifer Stately’s life terms run at the same time, with five years of supervised release and a $600 assessment. CBS Minnesota said life in prison and first-degree arson, and did not name the judge.

Life on all counts at the same time, plus five years of supervised release and a $600 assessment, and a life sentence with none of those terms on the page, are not the same sentence. First-degree arson, and arson, are not the same charge name. Red Lake Tribal Nation, the Red Lake Indian Reservation, the Red Lake Nation, and the Red Lake Reservation are not the same place name. Stab wounds, and sharp force injuries, are not the same wound line.

Read the take

Reporting noted by CBS Minnesota, Valley News Live, InForum, Northern News Now, and Star Tribune.

Cooper Ouellette in court
Trials

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer

NBC Connecticut said Cooper Ouellette will be sentenced January 12, 2027, and spelled him Ouelette. FOX61 said that date is a pre-sentencing hearing and the sentencing date is not set.

Manslaughter in the second degree, second-degree manslaughter, and second-degree vehicular manslaughter are not the same charge name. A decade plus a year-and-a-half, 10 years plus 11 months, and a maximum of 23 years are not the same penalty. $200,000, on FOX61, and a request to increase the bond with no dollar figure, on Courtroom Insider, are not the same bond line. He was 19 at the time, on NBC Connecticut, FOX61, and WFSB. He was 18, on Court TV and Courtroom Insider.

Read the take

Reporting noted by NBC Connecticut, FOX61, WFSB, Court TV, and Courtroom Insider.

Booking photo of Jaida McGrew
Trials

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer

News On 6 said a jury found Jaida McGrew guilty of murder in the first degree. The Tulsa World said second-degree murder.

Murder in the first degree, first-degree murder, and second-degree murder are not the same charge name. A deadly weapon, and a dangerous weapon, are not the same word. A jury recommendation, a 15-year term stated in one sentence, and a judge who has not yet sentenced, are not the same step. The News On 6 headline says a man. The update names Jaida McGrew. The Tulsa World says a woman. Those are not the same identification.

Read the take

Reporting noted by News On 6, Tulsa World, and Tulsa Police.