Skip to content

True Crime

Matthew Ammel pleaded not guilty, and the court raised his bond to $100,000 cash only.

Matthew Ammel pleaded not guilty on Monday, Oct. 12, 2026, in Maricopa County Superior Court to one count of felony criminal damage. azfamily reported that Commissioner Barbara Spencer set a $100,000 cash-only bond, up from $25,000. Prosecutors cited an alleged no-contact violation, a knife at a Phoenix gun store, and alleged threats against former Sen. Kyrsten Sinema and an unnamed North Carolina judge.

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer · · Updated

Booking photo of Matthew Ammel
Photo: Maricopa County Sheriff's Office

A not-guilty plea is a denial entered in court. It is not a finding that the damage happened, and it is not a finding that the texts are his. The new order is about custody. The bond is now $100,000 cash only. If he posts it, azfamily reported, the release terms are house arrest and an electronic monitor. Trial is set for Feb. 9, 2027. The state still has to prove the charge.

Matthew Ammel pleaded not guilty on Monday, Oct. 12, 2026, to one count of felony criminal damage, FOX 10 Phoenix and azfamily reported. The bond did not stay at $25,000. azfamily reported that Maricopa County Superior Court Commissioner Barbara Spencer set a $100,000 cash-only bond. The Arizona Republic reported that Judge Barbara Spencer raised the bond to $100,000 in cash at an arraignment that day. FOX 10 Phoenix reported that a judge granted the state's motion to raise the bond from $25,000 to $100,000 and did not name the judicial officer in the story. Commissioner and judge are different titles. The outlets are using both for Barbara Spencer. The dollar figure is the same. azfamily reported that if he posts the bond he would be on house arrest and electronic monitoring. The New York Post reported the same release terms. azfamily reported the trial is set for Feb. 9, 2027.

Prosecutors told the court the increase was about release conditions, not a new conviction. azfamily reported that Ammel was arrested on Sept. 18 on the damage allegation, released with orders not to contact Sinema and not to possess weapons, and arrested again on Sept. 29 after investigators said he went to a firearm retailer in Phoenix with a large hunting-style knife to be engraved and tried to contact her. The New York Post reported the Sept. 29 arrest was outside a Phoenix gun store and that he was accused of flouting the no-contact order. FOX 10 Phoenix dated that second arrest Sept. 30 and reported that investigators allege he tried to contact Sinema, was found with a large knife, and threatened Sinema, lawyers, and a sitting judge. Sept. 29 and Sept. 30 are a one-day difference. The knife, the gun store, and the alleged contact are in all three accounts.

In court Monday, prosecutors read messages they said Ammel sent. FOX 10 Phoenix quoted a prosecutor: "The defendant, talking about the crime victim, says 'no, she needs to be punished. She needs to pay.' In a separate text that same day, he, again, says she needs to pay." The same prosecutor read, "the police are on their way. I'm taking her down, no matter what it takes." azfamily reported the state pointed to alleged texts that read "she needs to pay" and "I'm taking her down no matter what it takes." The New York Post, citing 12News, put "She needs to pay" in a message it said he sent while telling a bail bondsman that Sinema should pay his bond. FOX 10 treated the bondsman call as a separate allegation. It quoted a prosecutor saying that since Ammel was back in custody he contacted a bail bondsman to contact her to post the bond, which the state called indirect contact barred by the no-contact order. A text about punishment and a request that she post a bond are not the same act. The outlets are not lining those quotes up the same way.

The North Carolina threat is also an allegation from Monday's hearing. FOX 10 Phoenix reported that prosecutors said that on Aug. 16 he wrote, in a group chat of military members and friends, about the judge in his North Carolina case, and that the message said he was going to decapitate that judge and kill the judge's family. The New York Post, citing 12News, reported the judge was not named and tied the message to a North Carolina case connected to his ex-wife's lawsuit. This story is not using the slur that appears in the quoted message. FOX 10 also reported that prosecutors said he threatened to kill lawyers and three officers in the North Carolina case, and that he previously pleaded guilty to assaulting a physician at a hospital in North Carolina. That prior guilty plea is a different case. It is not a verdict on the Cave Creek damage. The New York Post, citing 12News, reported that a victims' attorney told the court Sinema is reasonably and objectively afraid that if Ammel is released he will seriously injure her or someone else in the community. The Post's rendering of that sentence used brackets. It is the lawyer's argument, as that outlet reported it, not a finding.

The defense answer is on the record too. azfamily reported that Ammel's lawyer called the cash bond excessive, said he is seeking mental treatment while in custody, and said she believed the messages were sent before the offense date. A lawyer for the state told the court, azfamily reported, "I know it's a high bond. It seems disproportionate to the offense charge, but a high cash-only bond is the only way to protect the victim and the community, and to ensure he complies with court orders." Under the bond is still one count of felony criminal damage. The allegation, as earlier reporting and Monday's hearing described it, is more than $200,000 in damage at Sinema's Cave Creek home, including 22 paintings thrown into the pool. A grand jury indictment, a not-guilty plea, and a higher bond are not a verdict on that count. All defendants are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.

Share on XEmail

Get the take when the jury is out, the Court drops an order, or we go live.

Shop

Checkout is on Shopify. A few from the rack:

All merch

More on the desk