Skip to content

Trials

Two Get Bail in Malvern Kidnapping

Thabit Moussa, 18, and Marina Benyamen, 27, were granted bail Thursday in Melbourne on kidnapping and false-imprisonment charges. Police say a mother and her seven-year-old daughter were taken from a Malvern East home before dawn Tuesday and held in Clyde North. Prosecutors opposed the release.

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer ·

A mother and her daughter were taken from their home, locked in the boot of a car, and held until police found them. They were alive, and police said they were not physically injured. Bail on a finding that these two had a limited role is not an acquittal, and the kidnapping charges are still in front of them.

Thabit Moussa, 18, of Craigieburn, and Marina Benyamen, 27, of Craigieburn, were granted bail Thursday in the Melbourne Magistrates' Court. They are charged with common-law kidnapping, statutory kidnapping, and false imprisonment. The magistrate said the evidence at this stage suggested a limited role in the alleged kidnapping. Prosecutors asked that both stay in jail.

Police say a mother and her seven-year-old daughter were taken from their home in Malvern East shortly before 5 a.m. Tuesday. They were locked in the boot of a car and held at a property in Clyde North. Special Operations Group officers found them in the lounge room on Wednesday. Police said neither was physically injured. Moussa was arrested in the garage there. Benyamen was arrested in Craigieburn. She is accused of driving the car while the two were in the boot. Moussa gave police a no-comment interview.

The court was told a message on Moussa's phone, received after the abduction, read, "hey bro do you want to make some money tonight?" A second message read, "Make sure she is scared." Prosecutors described the kidnapping as a crime-for-hire arranged on an encrypted app, and said the pair had been willing to join something this serious at the outset. The prosecutor told the court they had started with a bang.

Moussa has no criminal record. The court was told this was Benyamen's first time in custody and that both have strong family backing. The magistrate told Moussa that whatever his role was, the offending was very serious, that the court was taking his age into account, and that he was lucky to be released. When Benyamen smiled from the dock, he warned her that a breach would be a simple decision and that she would go back into custody. Police have also arrested two other men, who have not been named. A 27-year-old from Roxburgh Park remained in hospital under guard. A 26-year-old from Roxburgh Park was arrested Thursday afternoon. The investigation is still open.

All defendants are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.

Share on XEmail

Get the take when the jury is out, the Court drops an order, or we go live.

Shop

Checkout is on Shopify. A few from the rack:

All merch

More on the desk