Skip to content

True Crime

Judge D.J. Mote sentenced Nigel Thomas to 65 years for murder and obstruction.

WHAS11 and WKRC Local 12 reported that Nigel Thomas, 36, of Oxford, Ohio, was sentenced to 65 years for the murder of Wilma Robertson, 35, of Hanover, and for obstruction. WHAS11 said the Oct. 26 term is 62 and a half years for murder plus two and a half years for obstruction, consecutive. Local 12 reported 65 years and did not print the split.

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer · · Updated

Booking photo of Nigel Thomas
Photo: FOX19

Monday's sentence is the judgment on the September guilty verdicts. It is not a new trial. WHAS11 put the murder term at 62 and a half years and the obstruction term at two and a half years, to run consecutively, for 65 years. WKRC Local 12 reported a 65-year sentence and did not break that number down. WHAS11 reported he will serve it in the Indiana Department of Correction.

WHAS11 and WKRC Local 12 reported that Nigel Thomas was sentenced for the murder of Wilma Robertson and for framing another man. WHAS11 reported the hearing was Oct. 26, 2026, in Jefferson County Circuit Court in Indiana, and that Judge D.J. Mote sentenced Thomas, 36, of Oxford, Ohio, to 62 and a half years for murder and two and a half years for felony obstruction of justice, consecutive, in the April 2025 killing of Wilma Robertson, 35, of Hanover. Local 12 reported he was sentenced Monday to 65 years and did not print the split or the judge's name. Sixty-two and a half plus two and a half is 65. The split is WHAS11's account. The single total is what both printed.

WHAS11 reported Robertson was found stabbed to death inside her home, that prosecutors presented victim-impact statements, and that her sister, Marsha Robertson, said, "I want Wilma to be remembered as more than the way she died – she was loved," and, "She mattered. She had a family who needed her." Local 12 printed the same remarks as one passage, without the dash. WHAS11 reported investigators testified about the arrest of Shawn Bailey, whom Thomas framed, and that Bailey had been in a relationship with Robertson. Local 12 reported investigators first arrested Bailey after someone received a video of Robertson's body from a social-media account using Bailey's name, that his phone was not near the scene, and that the account was accessed from Oxford while he was in jail. It reported prosecutors said Thomas created the fake accounts. Local 12 reported Thomas had sent Robertson hundreds of unanswered messages and that she had blocked several accounts before she was killed. Those are the accounts of the investigation given at sentencing. The guilty verdicts were already the jury's finding.

The two stories do not describe his statements in the same words. WHAS11 reported the state presented three recorded jail calls from after the conviction, and that Thomas, the aspiring rapper known as Nati Bang, urged family members to release a mixtape that included "Evil Soulmate," a song he recorded about Robertson. Local 12 reported that once he was arrested he asked his family to release a mixtape including that song. After the conviction, and once he was arrested, are not the same time. WHAS11 reported he told the court he "didn't choose" to throw his life away and that "Wilma is now free," and that the court said he did not show remorse and focused on how prison would affect his own life. Local 12 reported the prosecution said he showed no remorse, that he told the court he did not feel like a murderer or a monster, and that he said, "I didn't choose to throw my life away," and, "Wilma is now free." WHAS11 reported Judge Mote told him, "Your actions, Mr. Thomas, led to the arrest of a completely innocent man," and, "I can't imagine what he went through psychologically – and you did that." Local 12 reported the judge said, "You chose to kill her; you chose this future you are looking at. Ms. Robertson didn't choose this," and, "Her children didn't choose this." The children are not named here. WHAS11 reported Jefferson County Prosecutor David Sutter said, "Those crimes reached beyond Wilma and her family," and, "No sentence can undo the loss of Wilma and the lasting impact of her death on those who loved her." It reported Thomas will serve the sentence at the Indiana Department of Correction. A sentence after a guilty verdict is the court's judgment on those counts. All defendants are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.

Share on XEmail

Get the take when the jury is out, the Court drops an order, or we go live.

Shop

Checkout is on Shopify. A few from the rack:

All merch

More on the desk