Skip to content

Trials

Court Orders New Trial for Polo Edwards

The Mississippi Court of Appeals on Tuesday threw out William "Polo" Edwards's murder conviction and life sentence in the 2022 shooting of Robert Davis and ordered a new trial. The court said he was denied his right to a lawyer.

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer ·

Booking photo of William Ervin Edwards
Photo: WLBT

A reversal for a breakdown in the right to counsel wipes out the conviction and the life sentence. It does not decide who shot Robert Davis, and the state can put the case in front of another jury. The court held that trying the case after a refused continuance, without a lawyer prepared to defend it, was not a fair trial.

The Mississippi Court of Appeals on Tuesday reversed William Ervin Edwards's convictions and sent the case back to Hinds County for a new trial. Edwards, known as Polo, was sentenced to life in prison for the 2022 shooting death of Robert Davis, 45, and to 10 years for possessing a gun after a felony conviction. Judge David McCarty wrote the opinion. Chief Judge Donna Barnes and Judge Deborah McDonald joined it.

Edwards was indicted in 2022. The first jury could not reach a verdict. For the second trial the court appointed Brandon Dorsey. Edwards told the court that Dorsey went weeks without contacting him and did not get into the discovery. Eight days before that trial, Circuit Judge Faye Peterson denied a continuance. Dorsey was allowed to withdraw in the days before trial. Edwards said he did not want to represent himself. The court left him with a lawyer in a limited role, and the case was tried in December 2024.

The court was not of one mind on the reasoning. Judge Anthony Lawrence agreed in part and dissented in part. The judgment is still a reversal. Both convictions are set aside. The opinion does not decide whether Edwards shot Davis. The state has to try the case again. All defendants are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.

Share on XEmail

Get the take when the jury is out, the Court drops an order, or we go live.

Shop

Checkout is on Shopify. A few from the rack:

All merch

More on the desk