Skip to content

Trials

SABC News says the defense called Thabiso Buthelezi on Monday for Mthobisi Mncube in the Senzo Meyiwa trial in Pretoria.

The station's 1:57 p.m. SAST story on Nov. 9, 2026, says Buthelezi is testifying about a statement the late Simphiwe Buthelezi allegedly made. A 7:43 a.m. SAST story the same day said the trial was expected to resume after Thalente Ntombela finished on Thursday. Five men are on trial. SABC did not report a ruling.

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer ·

A witness describing what a dead man reportedly claimed is not that man's testimony. SABC's morning story said the High Court sitting was expected. The afternoon story says a new witness is on the stand. Expected, and on the stand, are not the same status. Five men standing trial is not a verdict.

SABC News, in a story time-stamped 9 November 2026 at 13:57 SAST and credited to Lerato Makola, reported that defense counsel in the Senzo Meyiwa murder trial called a new witness on behalf of accused number three, Mthobisi Mncube, at the High Court in Pretoria. It reported Thabiso Buthelezi is testifying about a statement allegedly made by the late Simphiwe Buthelezi, who reportedly claimed to have been involved in the illegal firearms trade with the accused. It reported the testimony seeks to shed light on the alleged relationship between Mncube and Simphiwe Buthelezi, and on information shared by the investigating team. It reported five men are standing trial for the murder of Meyiwa, and that Advocate Charles Mnisi is leading Buthelezi. It quoted Mnisi: "This court was told by the investigating team through the mouth of Brigadier Bongani Gininda that there was an interaction between them and Mr Simphiwe Buthelezi." The witness line, as the page printed it, begins "Yes, that's correct. Thank you." and does not close the quotation. The next Mnisi line, about the word interaction, is where the story fetched here ends. An exchange that stops on the page is not a completed cross-examination, and it is not a ruling. SABC did not print the word hearsay. It did not print an objection. It did not print a judge's name in that story.

The same station's story time-stamped 9 November 2026 at 07:43 SAST, also credited to Lerato Makola, reported the trial was expected to resume at the High Court in Pretoria on Monday morning, after the second witness for accused number three, Mthobisi Mncube, concluded his testimony on Thursday. Expected to resume, at 7:43 a.m., and a new witness called, at 1:57 p.m., are not the same status. The morning story named that Thursday witness as Thalente Ntombela, said he is related to accused number one, Muzi Sibiya, and said he disputed key state witness Constable Sizwe Zungu and alleged he was in KwaZulu-Natal on the day in question in 2014. It quoted state prosecutor Adv Ronnie Sibanda asking whether Sinakho (Sibiya) stayed in the same village, and it quoted Ntombela saying Sinakho came to Johannesburg in 2017 and had never set foot in Gauteng before that. The afternoon story does not print Ntombela, Sibiya, Zungu, or Sibanda. The morning story does not print Thabiso Buthelezi or Simphiwe Buthelezi. Accused number three, in both stories, is Mncube. The morning story's second witness for him, and the afternoon story's new witness for him, are not the same person. Five men standing trial, in the afternoon story, is the charge in court. It is not a finding. News24's Nov. 8 story on a complaint against the trial judge is not this witness. No IOL story of Monday's witness was read here. All defendants are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.

Share on XEmail

Get the take when the jury is out, the Court drops an order, or we go live.

Shop

Checkout is on Shopify. A few from the rack:

All merch

More on the desk

Booking photo of Dairyon McClendon
Trials

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer

The Journal Gazette says Dairyon Cortez McClendon was sentenced to 78 years. WPTA prints 60 years for murder and 18 years on a gun count and does not print 78.

Sixty plus 18 is 78 on The Journal Gazette. WPTA prints 60 and 18 and does not print the sum. Jurors, in the Journal Gazette lede, and a two-day bench trial, in the prosecutor's September 17 release, are not the same finder of fact. Vacated, on Monday's Journal Gazette story, is not the same status as a Monday story that still lists felony murder and does not say it was vacated. The 60 years and the 18 years are the sentence imposed Monday.

Read the take

Reporting noted by The Journal Gazette, WPTA, and AroundFortWayne.

Trials

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer

WXII says Ziyaire Spinks was in Forsyth County court Monday on a murder charge. NBC News, on Sunday, spelled him Ziyaire Antonyo Spinks.

A first appearance on Monday, on WXII, is not a trial date. Murder, on WXII and on the Associated Press account 9NEWS published, and murder plus assault with a deadly weapon with intent to kill inflicting serious injury, on NBC News, are not the same charge line. No bond, on all three, is the custody status they print. It is not a finding. WXII says he is due back Nov. 19. The Sunday pages do not print that date.

Read the take

Reporting noted by WXII, NBC News, 9NEWS, and Associated Press.

Gov. Gavin Newsom speaking into a microphone at a rally
Trials

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer

Newsom's Nov. 5 letter says he has decided to commute all 548 death sentences. The Los Angeles Times says about 40 percent need no court. His letter to the justices asks for a recommendation on 382.

Has decided, plans to change, will commute, and a headline that says he commutes are not the same tense. 382 of 548 is not about 40 percent, and it is not around 60 percent. A recommendation he has requested is not a commutation in effect. Life without parole, on the fact sheet, is not a release, not a pardon, and not a new finding on the conviction. Marc Klaas, in The Press Democrat, described the clemency as a knife in the back. The child is not named here.

Read the take

Reporting noted by Office of the Governor of California, Los Angeles Times, California Courts Newsroom, CBS 8, and The Press Democrat.