Skip to content

Trials

Court Lets Smith Press Death Claim

A three-judge panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ordered Todd Lee Smith's federal case paused so he can ask an Arizona court to hear a claim that his lawyers failed him at sentencing. The order does not lift his death sentence for the 1995 murders of Clarence and Elaine Tannehill.

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer ·

Clarence and Elaine Tannehill are dead, and the murder convictions stand. Wednesday's order does not resentence Smith. It lets him take a claim about the sentencing lawyers back to state court while the death sentence stays in place.

A three-judge panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Wednesday ordered a federal judge to pause Todd Lee Smith's habeas case. The pause is so he can ask an Arizona court to hear a claim that his lawyers failed him when he was sentenced to death. The order does not overturn the convictions or remove the death sentence. Smith is 77.

Clarence and Elaine Tannehill were found dead on Aug. 3, 1995, inside their travel trailer at the Ashurst Lake Campground off Lake Mary Road, near Flagstaff. They had been beaten, and their throats had been cut. Police arrested Smith in Phoenix three days later.

Smith argues that his trial lawyer did not present evidence of fetal alcohol syndrome and brain damage, or live testimony, at sentencing. His post-conviction lawyer admitted she never interviewed him and did not look for mitigation evidence beyond the trial record. The panel said the claim was potentially meritorious, which was enough to pause the federal case. It did not decide the sentence.

Share on XEmail

Get the take when the jury is out, the Court drops an order, or we go live.

Shop

Checkout is on Shopify. A few from the rack:

All merch

More on the desk