Skip to content

True Crime

The BBC named Abdillahi Farid Ali, 43, as the man fatally stabbed in Small Heath, and reported a 46-year-old man was arrested.

The BBC reported Thursday, Oct. 29, 2026, that police named Abdillahi Farid Ali, 43, as the man stabbed to death Wednesday afternoon in Small Heath, Birmingham, and that a 46-year-old man arrested nearby on suspicion of murder remained in custody. Birmingham Live put the stabbing shortly before 1:15 p.m. The BBC's Wednesday story put the call just after 13:15 GMT. The arrested man has not been named.

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer · · Updated

Thursday's naming is the identification of the man who died. The 46-year-old man has not been named. Just after 13:15 and shortly before 1:15 are not the same side of the same clock time. An arrest on suspicion is not a finding, and neither story reported a charge.

The BBC reported Thursday, Oct. 29, 2026, in a story by Eleanor Lawson, that a man who died after being stabbed in a busy street has been named by police. The BBC reported Abdillahi Farid Ali, 43, sustained knife wounds during an incident in Small Heath, Birmingham, on Wednesday afternoon and was declared dead at the scene. It reported a 46-year-old man was arrested nearby on suspicion of murder, that he remained in custody for questioning, and that police were not currently looking for anyone else. The Wednesday story on the same site, by Eleanor Lawson and Josh Sandiford and dated 28 October 2026, said officers were called just after 13:15 GMT to the junction of Whitmore Road and Coventry Road after a man in his 40s sustained knife wounds, that he was declared dead at the scene, and that a 46-year-old man was arrested nearby and remained in custody. Age 43 and a man in his 40s are not the same specificity. Wednesday afternoon, in Thursday's story, does not print 13:15. Birmingham Live, in a story by Harry Leach published at 14:44 on Oct. 29 and updated at 15:23, reported Abdillahi Farid Ali was fatally stabbed at the junction of Coventry Road and Whitmore Road shortly before 1:15 p.m. on Oct. 28, and that he was pronounced dead at the scene. Whitmore Road and Coventry Road, in the BBC's order, and Coventry Road and Whitmore Road, in Birmingham Live's order, are the same two roads in opposite sequence. Just after 13:15 GMT and shortly before 1:15 p.m. are opposite sides of one clock time. Declared dead and pronounced dead are not the same verb.

The BBC on Thursday quoted Det Insp Nick Barnes: "This was an extremely traumatising incident to witness, and we want to ensure that people are aware of the support available to them." The next quotation was, "Our thoughts remain with Mr Ali's family at this awful time. We are keeping them updated on any developments from the investigation." Birmingham Live quoted Detective Inspector Nick Barnes of West Midlands Police with the thoughts sentence first, then "We're keeping them updated on any developments from the investigation," then an appeal for witnesses who had not yet spoken to police, and then the traumatising sentence. Det Insp and Detective Inspector are not the same abbreviation. We are and We're are not the same form. Thursday's BBC story put the traumatising sentence before the thoughts sentence. Birmingham Live put the thoughts sentence first. Birmingham Live reported the 46-year-old man, arrested on suspicion of murder, was being questioned by detectives overnight and remained in custody this afternoon. Thursday's BBC story said he remained in custody for questioning and did not print overnight or this afternoon. The Wednesday BBC story said he remains in custody for questioning. Remained and remains are not the same tense. Birmingham Live reported the force reiterated that officers were not currently looking for any other suspects. Thursday's BBC story said they were not currently looking for anyone else. The Wednesday story said officers were not looking for anyone else. Anyone else and any other suspects are not the same phrase. Not currently, in the Thursday accounts, is a word the Wednesday story did not use.

The Wednesday BBC story reported a section of Coventry Road was closed, with heavy traffic and buses forced to turn around. Thursday's BBC story and Birmingham Live's naming story did not print the closure. The Wednesday story quoted a spokesperson: "We understand this has caused worry in the community, and we know there were a lot of people in the around at the time and saw what happened." In the around is the Wednesday wording. Thursday's BBC story said worry in the community, with a lot of people in the area around the junction of Whitmore Road and Coventry Road. Birmingham Live's spokesperson quotation said a lot of people in the area at the time. In the around and in the area are not the same phrase. Thursday's BBC story reported police are aware of distressing footage circulating online and urged people not to share it because it could affect the investigation, and that extra officers had been deployed. Birmingham Live reported detectives urged the public not to share video online because it could affect the investigation, and that a dedicated page had been set up where footage could be uploaded. A dedicated upload page is Birmingham Live's. Thursday's BBC story did not print it. Birmingham Live reported anyone with information should call 101 and quote 2482 of October 28, or call Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111. The Wednesday BBC story said to call 101 or contact Crimestoppers and did not print 2482 or 0800 555 111. Thursday's BBC story said people who witnessed it should get in touch and did not print those numbers. The 46-year-old man has not been named in any of the three accounts. An arrest on suspicion of murder is not a charge. All defendants are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.

Share on XEmail

Get the take when the jury is out, the Court drops an order, or we go live.

Shop

Checkout is on Shopify. A few from the rack:

All merch

More on the desk

True Crime

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer

The Multnomah County district attorney declined to prosecute Officer Daniel Hall in the fatal shooting of Eric Jonathan Hurtado.

Thursday's memo is the district attorney's decision not to present the shooting to a grand jury. It is not the Police Review Board's review, and Hall remains on administrative leave. The Oregonian's account of the memo moves from the St. Honore Bakery to the Oregon Wines store, the Dossier Hotel, and then the Vintage Hotel. KATU named the Kimpton Hotel Vintage at 422 S.W. Broadway. Those are not one address.

Read the take

Reporting noted by The Oregonian, KGW, KATU, KPTV, and Portland Police Bureau.

True Crime

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer

The Toronto Star reported David Morton and his daughters were shot in a Bridle Path home invasion.

Thursday's police account did not name the family. Friday's Star account did. CBC's 3:43 a.m. and CP24's around 3:45 a.m. are not the same clock. CBC's Thursday hammer account and CP24's Friday hammer account do not name the same people. The Daily Mail video put the break-in on Sunday.

Read the take

Reporting noted by Toronto Star, CBC, CP24, and Daily Mail.

Portrait of Dr. Stacey Fazenbaker
True Crime

By Crime Talk Network Staff Writer

A Hopkins County grand jury returned a no true bill for Dr. Stacey Fazenbaker.

A no true bill is the grand jury's decision not to indict. It is not a trial verdict. Insufficient evidence, in the Messenger's account of the release, and insufficient probable cause, in WFIE's story, are not the same words. About eight hours, several hours, and around nine hours are not the same length of time. The child is not named here.

Read the take

Reporting noted by WPKY, The Messenger, WFIE, Gray News, People, and Courier Journal.